The Appellate Group

Granite Sch. Dist. v. Young & Labor Comm’n

Granite Sch. Dist. v. Young & Labor Comm’n, 2026 UT 29 (Nielsen, J.)

Administrative

The Utah Supreme Court held:

(1) The Labor Commission did not err in upholding the ALJ’s instructions to the medical panel or the ALJ’s decision to not grant Granite leave to reopen the evidentiary record after the hearing.
(2) There was substantial evidence in the record to support the Commission’s findings that Young proved each element of her permanent total disability claim.
(3) The Commission did not err in refusing to grant Granite a subrogation offset.

Read the full court opinion