The Appellate Group

Ayala v. Unified Police Dept. and Mauger v. Unified Police Dept.

Ayala v. Unified Police Dept. and Mauger v. Unified Police
Dept.
, 2026 UT App 139 (Oliver, J.)

Civil Law

The Utah Court of Appeals held, in a consolidated opinion, that:

The district court erred by granting summary judgment to Unified PD because there were multiple disputes of material facts regarding Unified PD’s governmental immunity defense.

Practice tip:

The failure to show that an officer’s lights or siren was adequate under the governing statute is fatal to a motion for summary judgment.

Read the full court opinion