The Appellate Group

Ream v. Ream

Ream v. Ream, 2025 UT App 105 (Oliver, J.)

Civil Procedure

The Utah Court of Appeals held:

  • The district court properly took judicial notice of Petitioner’s statements and was free to consider them in its credibility determination. 
  • The district court’s findings regarding whether Respondent knowingly violated the injunction were not against the clear weight of the evidence. 
  • Practice tip: The court noted “wrinkles” in the civil-stalking statute: (1) it seems to allow an individual to avoid both civil and criminal responsibility for violating a temporary injunction by simply not reading the injunction, and (2) it seems to allow an individual to obtain a stalking injunction without meritorious allegations because the injunction can be issued before an evidentiary hearing is held. 

Read the full court opinion